Vervoe logo

5 min read

“Why should we hire you?” — 5 Outdated Interview Questions Recruiters Should Avoid

The first recorded job interview in history took place in 1921, when Thomas Edison designed a written test to help evaluate a candidate’s knowledge. Since then, not a lot has changed.

Recruiters have been submitting candidates to the same set of outdated interview questions for decades. Interviews have become less about finding the best candidate for the role, and more about testing to see how a candidate can perform a series of rehearsed answers. Questions like “why should we hire you?” are not designed to bring out the best in a candidate – nor are they designed to give a recruiter any depth of information that one would need to make a great hire. Isn’t it most important to test a candidate’s skills, technical qualifications, and cultural fit?

It’s time to evolve past the 1920s with a better way to hire candidates. Here are the five most outdated interview questions – and a better alternative to recruiting the best talent for your company.

Why should we hire you?

As a recruiter, it’s your job to know what skills the position requires. The question ‘why should we hire you?’ asks the job seeker to justify why they are the right person for you – and that’s a problem. “You know the job inside and out, or you should if you are interviewing candidates for it – they don’t. It is up to you as the interviewer to ask real-life, practical questions about work that is performed in the role in order to assess the candidate’s suitability for the job,” says one recruitment expert.  

Another problem with the question ‘why should we hire you?’ is the premise that a candidate must prove their worth to the company. Instead, an interview should work as a two-way conversation. Is this a good match for both parties? What would it look like for the company and the candidate to collaborate together?

What’s your greatest weakness?

In addition to ‘why should we hire you?’, the question ‘what’s your greatest weakness?’ attempts to learn what an AI-powered skills test can uncover with just a few questions. Not every candidate (or employee) is good at everything – and that’s ok. No one is perfect. But all too often, candidates turn this question around and attempt to highlight a strength. This question will never elicit an authentic or honest response. Instead, use a skills test or a talent trial to really learn how a candidate will fit into their team.

Where do you see yourself in five years?

In asking this question, the recruiter seems to suggest what the candidate’s answer should be: with this company, of course. It forces the candidate to be disingenuous (or worse, dishonest). Everyone in the room knows a lot can change in five years, and a candidate may not stay with the company forever. However, answering anything less than 100% confidence you’ll be loyal to the job makes a candidate look like less of a team player.

Tell me about yourself.

According to one recruiter, this question is bad for two reasons. First, it conveys a lack of interest or preparation on the part of the recruiter. Once a candidate is at the interview stage, they’ve likely already submitted their LinkedIn profile, resume, cover letter, and more. Shouldn’t the recruiter know something about the candidate by now?

Second, this question is too open-ended, and as a result, there are two common things that can happen when a candidate tries answer this question. A candidate who has practiced can deliver a shiny, packaged narrative that makes them stand out. Or, a candidate can get nervous and bungle the question, immediately disqualifying themselves in the eyes of the interviewer. Either way, the recruiter isn’t getting any insight into the candidate’s skills or fit for the company.

Tell me about a time when you failed.

Like the “weakness” question, this candidate is asked to show how well they’ve prepared for the interview with a rehearsed anecdote designed to bring out a positive feature, rather than a failure. What does a person’s past failure tell you about their potential for future success? It’s a negative question that can make an anxious candidate feel even more nervous.

How to update your interview questions

What’s a better way to screen candidates while avoiding ‘why should we hire you?’ And these other outdated interview questions? Skills testing is one way to weed out the cream of the crop from the bad apples. Instead of combing through useless resumes or asking the same tired questions, recruiters are using integrated skills and attitude testing to get a 360-degree evaluation of lots of candidate’s talent.

Ask candidates to perform real-world tasks to make hiring more about merit, rather than about interview preparation. Case studies or group interviews are one way to do this, but there are also tools that provide a customizable interview experience for each open position. From quick surveys to rigorous talent assessments, the best interview questions combine psychometric assessments with skills testing. See how a candidate actually performs against the position description, rather than interview questions created last-century.

Why should we hire you? Interview

 

Picture of Emily Heaslip

Emily Heaslip

Emily Heaslip is a wordsmith extraordinaire, weaving narratives that captivate and compel audiences across digital realms. With over eight years of experience in the art of storytelling, Emily has mastered the craft of freelance copywriting, infusing SEO strategies and content marketing tactics to craft captivating tales for brands such as HelloFresh, ADAY, and BlackRock. As the founder of Emily Heaslip Copywriting, Emily channels her creative energy into delivering unparalleled copywriting services that resonate with clients and audiences alike. Her journey from journalism to global relief efforts has imbued her writing with depth and authenticity, setting her apart as a versatile writer with a unique perspective. When she's not crafting captivating content, Emily can be found mentoring budding writers, sharing her wealth of knowledge and experience to empower the next generation of storytellers. With a passion for words and a talent for communication, Emily continues to inspire and connect through the power of storytelling.

Recent articles

Featured articles

Similar articles you may be interested in​

Internships bridge the gap between academic learning and real-life work experience, allowing companies to nurture future talent. While interns bring

June 4, 2025

Microsoft Excel has been a key tool in businesses for nearly 40 years, and the demand for candidates with strong

May 15, 2025

The right C++ interview questions go beyond testing surface-level technical knowledge of candidates. Beyond knowing syntax, a strong hire needs

May 15, 2025

Popular assessments

The skills tested in this skills assessment for an Administrative Clerk determine whether the candidate can communicate well, both written and verbally, and if they have the ability to engage with multiple personality types. We test to see if the candidate is capable of using their initiative and think pragmatically in an ever changing role

The skills tested in this Assessment for an Administration Officer determine whether the candidate can communicate and articulate themselves verbally and face to face, we tested whether the candidate can organise their day effectively in order to insure the completion of many different tasks, and f they have the knowledge to assist with Technology set up and issues if they arise.

The skills tested in this assessment for a Virtual Assistant is to determine whether the candidate has experience and proficiency in Microsoft and systems to enable them to complete administrative tasks with ease. We tested whether the candidate can communicate well with others from an remote environment and whether they have the discipline and self motivation to work productively in a solo environment.

The skills tested in this assessment for a Secretary include determining how the candidate can cope with dealing with uncomfortable situations while remaining professional and calm. this assessment tested to gauge the level of communication the candidate has and their attention to detail.

The skills tested in this assessment for an Executive Assistant include determining whether the candidate can be discrete with tasks and people holding a level of professionalism. We tested to determine if the candidate has both written and verbal communication skills and if they are able to handle a busy workload with the ability to multitask exceptionally.

A Data Analyst should be proficient in maths but, most importantly, demonstrate a strong business sense. Through this combination, they can drive change to the business based on pieces of information they derive from data. Specifically, in the Vervoe skill assessment, the following skills are looked at in detail, critical thinking, use of data models in different situations, and data classification for the different problem sets.

The skills that are tested in this assessment for a Copywriter include how skilled the candidate is in SEO, copywriting, creative thinking, and research. It tests their ability to plan, design, and create advertising campaigns, the process they would follow before writing content for SEO, their process for creating a landing page, the research, and resources they would utilize when working with a new client, as well as the research they would conduct once being assigned to a project they had little knowledge about.